Right Anglespondering how to walk uprightly in a crooked world
About this Entry
Posted by: RightAngles

Visit RightAngles's Xanga Site

Original: 10/28/2005 1:12 PM
Views: 1
Comments: 7
eProps: 6

Read Comments
Post a Comment
Back to Your Xanga Site


Who gave the eProps?
2 eProps!2 eProps! 2 eProps from:
pelachito
BeatriceG
anselm_the_presbyterian

Friday, October 28, 2005

 The question of what makes an artist fascinates me, which is partly why I chose to do the term paper for my class on nineteenth century American literature on Emerson's philosophy of art. I've been reading from The Culture of Interpretation: Christian Faith and the Postmodern World by Roger Lundin for background on the Romantic philosophy of art and the artist. Lundin brings out the close connection between Romanticism and Postmodernism, which I must admit I never thought to associate with each other. I've heard Modernism and Postmodernism compared and contrasted within an inch of their lives (such as they are), but Romanticism and Postmodernism? Not really. I didn't know that the notion of projecting, rather than discovering, a world, took off with Kant, who said that, The intellect does not derive its laws (a priori) from nature but prescribes them to nature. It's the artist's job, according to Kant and the Romantics, to create a world with his imagination, to express himself, not to accurately reflect an existing world (Heaven forbid, that would be unoriginal!). Instead of understanding Nature as the self-revelation of a God both immanent and transcendent, Nature was understood as a reflection of the human mind, a tool for revealing humanity to itself.

No wonder by the twentieth and twenty-first centuries, we feel trapped in ourselves!

"In Mexico City they somehow wandered into an exhibition of paintings by the beautiful Spanish exile Remedios Varo: in the central painting of a triptych, titled "Bordando el Manto Terrestre," were a number of frail girls with heart-shaped faces, huge eyes, spun-gold hair, prisoners in the top room of a circular tower, embroidering a kind of tapestry which spilled out the slit windows and into a void, seeking hopelessly to fill the void: for all the other buildings and creatures, all the waves, ships and forests of the earth were contained in this tapestry, and the tapestry was the world. Oedipa, perverse, had stood in front of the painting and cried. . . . She had looked down at her feet and known, then, because of a painting, that what she stood on had only been woven together a couple thousand miles away in her own tower, was only by accident known as Mexico, and so Pierce had taken her away from nothing, there'd been no escape." (The Crying of Lot 49 by Thomas Pynchon, 1965).

Have you noticed how terribly we want connection, communication, how much we want to be known? (To ask it another way: have you noticed how many people crave romantic relationships as if they alone give life meaning?) It makes you wonder if people need reassurance that they're not alone, that the world isn't all illusion and there IS an objective reality.

Exalting the self and the individual hasn't landed us in a very pleasant place.
 Posted 10/28/2005 1:12 PM - 1 view - 7 comments

Give eProps or Post a Comment

7 Comments

Visit pelachito's Xanga Site!
I want to read your paper. Please send it to me when you finish! I've had some long discussions with K.S. over art's definition and related issues. I hate not having my mind thoroughly made up, but I'll live.
Posted 10/29/2005 3:55 PM by pelachito - reply

Visit BeatriceG's Xanga Site!

Karoline, this is an excellent post; I've reread it several times.

"Have you noticed how terribly we want connection, communication, how much we want to be known?"

Hence all our blogs... :)

"To ask it another way: have you noticed how many people crave romantic relationships as if they alone give life meaning?"

lol! Like girls who say, "Wow, this sunset is beautiful... wouldn't it be great to have someone [meaning boyfriend] to share it with?" :) Forget the siblings, best friends or grandmothers with them... enjoying the world is incomplete without a relationship. :)

"It makes you wonder if people need reassurance that they're not alone, that the world isn't all illusion and there IS an objective reality."

I think it's in the movie "Shall We Dance" when the wife asks the psychiatrist why people fall in love. I forget what his reply was, but whatever it was she disagreed with it and said exactly what your second-to-last paragraph said: it's so that we know we're not alone, so that someone is with us and we know that someone else sees our life and is there through it all. Interesting... :)

Posted 10/29/2005 5:59 PM by BeatriceG - reply

Visit anselm_the_presbyterian's Xanga Site!

I've been accustomed to view it from a different light: since man is created in the image of the Trinity, community and relatinoship are somehow the whole context in which man lives, whether he knows it or not.  One who is truly isolated is hardy human at all.

But I think your point fits neatly into the previous: if our first and highest relationship is not to our Creator, and if He is not the foundation of all other community, there is inevitably a void.  Since the image of the Trinity is still inherent in us, we seek context and meaning in other forms of relationship, and that is what drives a godless people to seek connection.

It reminds me of that Lewis quote:  "God is the noun; we are the adjectives."  Humans have no meaning except as God exists to define it.  And ideas have consequences: if we believe there is no God, we can't find our true definition in our relation to Him--we have to find it somewhere else.

Posted 10/30/2005 4:41 PM by anselm_the_presbyterian - reply

Visit anselm_the_presbyterian's Xanga Site!
Bleh.  I can't type these days.  I blame it on the weather: this cold makes my fingers stiff. 
Posted 10/30/2005 4:45 PM by anselm_the_presbyterian - reply

Visit RightAngles's Xanga Site!
Oh dear, John, does that mean my paper has to be coherent? <g> I'll send it along when it's done.

Thank you Emily. :) I'm glad you understand my meaning! I don't want to imply that community is unimportant, that it's wrong to want romance. When having "cool" people to "hang with", or having a "special someone" comes to comprise your entire identity, that's when it betokens great emptiness and great fear. Those in that situation either run away from everything unlike themselves, or cling for dear life to practically everyone.

In some ways, they're the hardest people to minister to, but in some ways, they're the easiest.
Posted 10/30/2005 4:53 PM by RightAngles - reply

Visit RightAngles's Xanga Site!
Wow, just missed you Kent!

Objectively, no human is utterly isolated, I agree completely. The isolation I have in mind is a sense of spiritual and psychological isolation - a terrible, almost crippling, fear of inability to communicate meaning to someone else. Since God alone is the source and ground of all being or identity, we will only become ourselves (as God meant us to be!) in relation to Him. It takes faith and fearful courage to reject everything else that claims to comprise our ultimate identity - friends, family, teachers, books, or cultures.

On the other hand, these all play into our identity, once it is founded on this, that we are bondservants of Christ Jesus. They help to nourish, as well as to work out our identity. God has commanded us to love one another, and that means rejoicing with those who rejoice, and weeping with those who weep. It's impossible to do that if we don't know one another, and know one another well. The heart knows its own bitterness, and a stranger does not share its joy. If we are being built together in Christ into a holy temple, we must know, love, and minister to one another.
Posted 10/30/2005 5:11 PM by RightAngles - reply

Visit anselm_the_presbyterian's Xanga Site!
Perzackly.
Posted 10/30/2005 9:33 PM by anselm_the_presbyterian - reply


Choose Identity
(?)
 
Give eProps (?)
Post a Comment
Add Link | Preview HTML comment help 


Back to RightAngles's Xanga Site!
Note: your comment will appear in RightAngles's local time zone:
GMT -05:00 (Eastern Standard - US, Canada)