Thursday, June 26, 2008

  • I just finished reading a really good book. Before I got a job I was spending all my time at borders and I saw this book with a picture of two nearly identical people, one a woman one a man. "Self Made Man; one womans year as a man," said the title in bold friendly letters (I heart Douglas Adams)

    And so I found one of the many big armchairs around the store and began to read. The author is a lady named Norah. She's a lesbian, and has been told all her life that she is mannish and unfeminine. But more than that, she sees the liberties society has historically given men, and wants to experience life from the other side.

    Whenever I hear 'lesbian' I automatically assume the man hating variety. I'm not sure why. I know lesbians and gay people, and in every case, they're regular people who don't fit as neatly into their political archetypes as I'd expect them to,

    But still, knowing the authors background, I expected an embittered, cynical rant against the baser sex. But I was pleasantly surprised by her insights and her beautiful portraits of men she met and befriended as "Ned". She writes about brotherhood and comraderie, which she says is foreign to women. And, perhaps most astoundingly, she writes with great sympathy for the role society gives men. Traditionally, the only negative emotion men have been allowed to feel is anger. Hurt and sadness are womanly feelings.

    I know I've encountered this. I see men all the time who can't articulate their emotional state beyond being "wicked pissed!" or some such nonsense.

    She also goes on to talk about the male facade of confidence, which society demands. Since the sexual revolution of the sixties, she writes, men are expected to be sensitive and liberal, respectful and introspective, erstwhile being strong, confident and secure and aloof. She wonders allowed if both extremes are possible simultaneously.

    many of the men she encounters as Ned (her male alter ego) are 'faking it'. They feel inadequate, weak,  ill equipped and self conscious, but act macho, self reliant, and strong.

    Yesterday at work I was talking to a co worker about this beautiful girl who wroks at the factory with us. I told him she intimidated me, and I always found something to do when I saw her coming, so as to avoid eye contact.

    His response could have been part of the aforementioned book. "I'm not the hottest shit in the world, either. I mean, Jesus! Look at me,"

    I love this guy, he's sort of a redneck. A little on the portly side. One of those scruffy heavy metal goatees,

    "Whenever I don't feel confident, I fake it. People buy that shit, man. Nobody thinks twice."

    And he's right! No one does. I wondered, after he said that how many things in life that might be true of. Can a bad singer "fake it" with confidence and become a good singer? Probably, eventually.

    Then I thought about John Wesley. I don't remember the exact phrasing, but I remember a friend of mine telling me that Wesley's mentor told him (during a period of existential doubt) to act as if he had faith until his faith came back. Or, in laymans terms, to fake it until it's real.

    Returning to the topic of the book, one wonders if thats all gender is, a series of faked poses and attitudes which we adopt over time until they are us.

    Anyway, just some random thoughts. It's definitely a book worth reading.

    peace

    ben



Comments (6)

  • sanildefanso

    Not that being a woman is any picnic, but I certainly agree that men get loads of mixed messages as to how they should behave, and what their attitudes should be, both from women and from men. Good post, dude.

    I miss you. Hope things are going well with the job.

  • lumberjakbarbie
    Dunk!

    Fake it until it's real... I never could get that to work quite right.  Doesn't 'faking it' about anything just make people feel deceptive or guilty until their lives are basically formed around those things and whatever they were originally faking falls into place because it is now a lesser evil?  And why am I acting like that's a question when I know that's how it works.  For me, anyway.  Ah but I am one of those picnics Nate mentioned...


    I've always hated how society decided one day that men should be more feminine and then the next day they started bashing them for being feminine.  Like that wasn't the plan...  I'm already afraid to send my kids to kindergarten, because who knows what they'll be teaching toddlers, 10 years from now?!  Be girly, be manly, be both, be neither.  There are just too many options.


    It's interesting that she writes about brotherhood and comradery being foreign to women, too.  I haven't read the book so I can't comment intelligently (so what am I doing, you may ask...) but that is all up to expecations, too.  A few girls decide they're supposed to be silly and gossipy and uptight and that sets the norm for the rest of the girls who may be perfectly capable of comradery but instead are banished to be self-conscious loners, cringing away from their expected roles.  It doesn't have to be that way.  I've seen both sides and...


    Hey, where did all of these soap boxes come from?!  I thought I felt taller.  Shutting up now.  

  • ShortCountry

    I yelled at you on facebook; i retract it...


    I was having a bad day... annnnnd yeah i miss you and you "um you're twisted" me and .... oy. I miss you.


    I want to hang out soon. Or, you know... talk... like we did back in 'nam.


    Thanks for appreciating my post.


    I believe you're brilliant too.



    Love you

  • ShortCountry

    as far as this thing... i couldnt even begin to wrap my brain around the concept of 'faking' it. . . i dont understand this....

  • mvnulife4life

    hmmm...this sounds like an interesting book. I'm glad you posted about it. It seems that if you allow yourself to stand far enough back and let yourself be a genderless being in space, there are a lot of things that we do that don't make sense. i.e. some of the gender roles you mentioned. Maybe rather than admitting how silly we are as a society we just keep going and pretending like it's all normal. I'm not sure. The whole faking it thing scares me.
    Good post, I miss your insight.

  • sanildefanso

    To answer your question, I actually liked the new indiana Jones movie a lot. My only two criticisms were that 1) the plot was pretty thrown together and 2) it was willfully silly more than any of the others.


    Having said that, I had a blast watching it, and if this weren't such a busy summer with movies, I'd probably see it again. It had the same harkening to old cheesy serials that the other ones do, and I felt it stayed true to the spirit of the whole series. Good job, all!
  • Choose Identity

  • Give eProps (?)

  • New! You can now edit your comments for 15 minutes after submitting.

Who recommended?

Who gave the eProps?