Show me the muny
About this Entry
Posted by: chanctw

Original: 2/20/2006 6:05 PM
Views: 6
Comments: 6
eProps: 6

Read Comments
Post a Comment
Back to Your Xanga Site


Who gave the eProps?
2 eProps!2 eProps! 2 eProps from:
johnlai2004
ToroHaro
minhdog


Monday, February 20, 2006

 

During lunch today, Harold inquired about my past inclination to explore a career in China. Two years ago, driven by dreams of glory and riches, I thought that China was a vast market waiting to be tapped with myriad opportunities. I have since been convinced otherwise.

A lot of people are blinded by Shanghai's glitter. They look at the shining towers and think that liberty will arrive alongside prosperity. Here's a word of caution: to those who see Shanghai as the new Barcelona, the Chinese city is no more than a funky destination for the adventurous traveller. The rulers of China seem to have realized that, if they can become rich without ceasing to be a police state, they can remain rich, and grow wealthier still, without sacrificing any of their power. In Shanghai and Beijing, one would do well to remember that among the freeways, the Italian gourmet restaurants and the supermarkets, there is still an unapologetic police state. Just because the People's Republic is on the verge of mastering the art of the caffé latte, do not for one second think that the newspaper you read with your coffee will be uncensored.

I have been to a number of places in China, including Guangzhou suburbs and Inner Mongolia. Here, freedom means thousands of sweatshops turning out handbags and backpacks, often under signs with messages such as "Work hard today or you will be looking hard for work tomorrow." The workforce, doing their 15-hour day and their six-day week for $160 CAD a month, are far better off than their peasant parents in the Hunan ricefields. And if you go to those ricefields, you will find that it is true.

The countryside is lovely, but the houses are squalid and the iron fist of authority is heavy and cruel. One would think there is something to be said of the official one-child policy until he finds out women, who dare to have a second son and fail to pay the fine for doing so, are terrorized by state-sponsored thugs.

The Chinese Communist Party recently introduced the Web Police -- anybody who has ever read 1984 would discover its striking similarity with the Thought Police that dominates the Orwellian world. In today's National Post newspaper, there was an article about the ubiquitous cartoon figures -- dubbed "Jian Jian" and "Cha Cha", which are the Chinese characters for "police" -- that follow you wherever you surf in the Internet system that is heavily filtered by the state. Chinese laws forbid comments that criticize the political order and the "honour of national institutions." The cartoon couple, albeit cute and lovely looking, means serious business: they represent real Web Policemen that seek and prosecute all those who dare violate the laws.

A Chinese policeman expressed that "the web police exist all over the world, but they always operate in the back stage. Here in China, we have invented Jian Jian and Cha Cha as front-line cops who work in the front stage. This is a major historic breakthrough. Our concept is truly brilliant: the cartoon figures will always follow wherever you go on the Internet, serving as a reminder that you are constantly being watched." He further expanded that "the U.S. and President Bush should consider adopting our system to treat those who harshly criticize the government."

What an awesome concept indeed. Imagine what would happen here in North America if the Bush Administration even hints at the notion of dedicating police resources to conspicuously monitor the Web. This Chinese cop is obviously ignorant of the essence of U.S. and Canadian Constitutions that deter precisely such things.

It is interesting to note that human rights and the freedom of speech similar to those of the West are enshrined in China's official Constitution. But whether the Chinese authorities actually enforce these constitutional rights is an entirely different matter -- it makes me wonder why they installed the Constitution in the first place. Clearly it is not there to protect people's rights. Is it, then, just a smokescreen set up to deceive the world?

China is not a country but a colossal imperium with a giant reservoir of willing labour available to fuel cheap growth. It is unrestrained by the great ideas of the West that keep us from being too cruel or ruthless, and which have created our concern with conscience and the freedom to exercise it.

My home is in Canada. It would be imprudent for me to abandon my family and everything I have worked hard to achieve, and head off to China in search for opportunities that are dubious at best. Therefore, Harold, I think I will be fine here in North America.

 Posted 2/20/2006 6:05 PM - 6 views - 6 comments

Give eProps or Post a Comment

6 Comments

Visit johnlai2004's Xanga Site!
There are several phases to societal/human development. Freedom is one of those intermediate phases. The phase prior to freedom is survival. Maybe China needs to grow slowly, one step at a time. Maybe excessive freedom is detrimental to a nation that's working its way back to the world as the center nation?

????
Posted 2/20/2006 9:21 PM by johnlai2004 - reply

Visit chanctw's Xanga Site!
As long as the Communist Party is in power, there's little chance for there to be "excessive freedom," regardless of the current phase of societal development.
Posted 2/21/2006 12:30 AM by chanctw - reply

Visit johnlai2004's Xanga Site!
does it really matter at this point that there's no freedom? I just figured freedom is for citizens who are ready for it. Maybe there are pre-requisites? You don't want a total revolution cause that's normally bad for a nation, and at the same time, you want some kind of progress.
Posted 2/21/2006 10:02 AM by johnlai2004 - reply

Visit chanctw's Xanga Site!

Well, it matters for me. Remember the focus of this post was to explain the reasons why I don't want to go to China anymore.

Posted 2/21/2006 11:04 AM by chanctw - reply

Visit ToroHaro's Xanga Site!

That's an awesome piece! I can see how your decision to stay in North America evolved.

I am glad that you see past the allure of opportunities for wealth in China. Afterall, we are talking about one of the harshest regime on earth against political dissenters. The notion of true freedom is seriously in question. What lies beneath the apparent economic prosperity remains to be grasped.  Clearly, you have greater insights than many of us......

The idea of web-policing is further supported by the recent inquiry of 4 prominent Internet companies at the US congressional hearings regarding their co-operation with Chinese authorities, and how the Chinese government blatantly deny arrests and censorships. For details, please see: http://www.theglobeandmail.com/servlet/story/RTGAM.20060220.gtchinainternet18/BNStory/Technology/home

Even if you did not find fault with the Chinese system, your attachment to Toronto and the people here may make you stay nonetheless.

Home is where the heart is. That's so true.

Posted 2/21/2006 12:04 PM by ToroHaro - reply

Visit minhdog's Xanga Site!
that was quite the eye-opener. Nicely written and very compassionate.
Posted 3/6/2006 2:49 AM by minhdog - reply


Choose Identity
(?)
 
Give eProps (?)
Post a Comment
Add Link | Preview HTML comment help 
  • Say it with Minis! (?)

Profile Pic:
Default  |  Choose »  (?)



Back to chanctw's Xanga Site!
Note: your comment will appear in chanctw's local time zone:
GMT -05:00 (Eastern Standard - US, Canada)