Monday, January 14, 2008

  • Thoughts?

    Chad aid workers in French court
    French prosecutors are calling for an eight-year prison sentence for all six accused [EPA]
    Six French aid workers sentenced to eight years hard labour in Chad for attempted kidnapping have been back in court, but this time in France.
     
    The six members of the charity Zoe's Ark were repatriated to France in December after they were found guilty of trying to fly more than 100 African children to Europe.
    bodyVariable350="Htmlphcontrol1_lblError";
    But the sentence of hard labour does not exist in French law, so a court is now deciding what their equivalent punishment should be.
    bodyVariable300="Htmlphcontrol2_lblError";
    Under the terms of a judicial co-operation agreement with Chad, they were repatriated to France where they are expected to serve normal prison sentences as French law does not allow forced labour.
     
    Suitable sentence
     
    The state prosecutor in the Paris suburb of Creteil called for an eight-year prison sentence.
     
    "The most suitable sentence would be eight years in prison," Jean-Jacques Bosc told the court, convened to convert the hard labour sentence.
     
    He said Monday's hearing was a purely technical procedure.
     
    The workers were trying to fly 103 children from
    Chad to place in European foster care [AFP]
    "We are not holding a new trial here. You cannot reconsider the facts or revise the sentences. Taking this path would be to violate an international principle," he said.
     
    But a new trial is exactly what defence lawyers want.
     
    They said before the hearing opened that the Chadian sentences were not valid because they were imposed in what they described as an undemocratic state and after a trial which they said was not fair.
     
    The Creteil criminal court said it would hand down a ruling on January 28.
     
    The aid workers were arrested in October as they tried to fly 103 children, aged one to 10, from eastern Chad to Europe for fostering with families there.
     
    They said they had been on a humanitarian mission to rescue orphans from Sudan's war-torn Darfur region, across Chad's eastern border.
     
    But most of the children were found to have come from families in Chadian border villages who gave them up on promises of education and healthcare for the boys and girls.
     

    http://english.aljazeera.net/NR/exeres/CC191B4C-FE71-4E39-86B7-240794A2B9B5.htm

     

Comments (2)

  • stary9er

    not sure why they were repatriated back to france... but i wonder if the justice system in Chad returned them with conditions that they would be given the same punishment or what. i would think this hasnt been the first time things like this have happened between countries. is there an agreement made when people are repatriated? 

  • stary9er

    yeah, depending from what perspective, it would be a positive effort, or a crime... or a positive effort that at the same time is a crime.  kind of a sticky situation to get in taking children from families that are okay with it, but the government not being okay with it. and i know the US has some history of taking babies illegally with other countries. i watched a documentary about stuff that went down with vietnam. even when i was in guatemala, they said in some areas we should be extra careful about taking pictures of children because for whatever reasons foreigners have been blamed for taking children.
    i think it could easily look not so great to certain people for foreigners to swoop in, take their children and basically make promises that we can give them better lives. even if that might be the case generally speaking. i dont know, thoughts  :)

  • Choose Identity

  • Give eProps (?)

  • New! You can now edit your comments for 15 minutes after submitting.

Who recommended?

Who gave the eProps?

2 eProps from: